York County, Pennsylvania Well Water Quality

Last Updated:

25%of homes on private wellsEPA 2020 estimate
4 gpgtypical hardness317 homeowner samples
46%tested positive for coliform bacteria722 homeowner samples
200 fttypical well depth20,688 well records

York County Well Water at a Glance

Coliform bacteria in 46% of samples. 46% of 722 homeowner samples tested positive for coliform bacteria, close to the Pennsylvania rate of 44%. Most positives trace back to surface water getting into the well.

Safe to drink? Test for nitrate first; it is the main risk here.

What a typical home here installs:

  1. A whole-house sediment filter first, so sand and scale do not foul the stages after it.
  2. An acid neutralizer if your pH tests below 6.5 (42% of homeowner samples here fell outside 6.5 to 8.5).
  3. Point-of-use an RO system at the kitchen tap for nitrate, once a lab test confirms it in your well.
  4. After a positive bacteria test, shock chlorinate, then add a UV unit at the end of the line if coliform comes back.

See how a well water filtration system is laid out. Your own test result decides the final list.

Not sure what to install? Get a filter recommendation for York County homes

On city or county water instead? Your utility publishes an annual water quality report; this page covers private wells. Find your utility's report

On this page (10 sections)

Where to Test Well Water in York County

Call before you go; hours and fees change.

What Are You Noticing in Your Water?

Suggested starting point:

Confirm with a lab test before buying equipment.

Explore Pennsylvania Interactive Map

Explore York County and nearby counties

Elk CountyCarbon CountyBlair CountySomerset CountyErie CountyFayette CountyJuniata CountyMcKean CountyMifflin CountyMontgomery CountyWarren CountyMontour CountyDelaware CountyAdams CountyLehigh CountyNorthampton CountyCumberland CountyFranklin CountyLuzerne CountyPotter CountyAllegheny CountyBucks CountyLycoming CountyLebanon CountyCentre CountyPike CountySusquehanna CountyWashington CountyUnion CountyCrawford CountyVenango CountyLancaster CountyArmstrong CountyWestmoreland CountyBeaver CountyForest CountyTioga CountyDauphin CountyWayne CountyGreene CountyJefferson CountySnyder CountyClarion CountyClearfield CountyIndiana CountyPerry CountyCameron CountyButler CountyPhiladelphia CountyFulton CountyBradford CountyHuntingdon CountyBedford CountyLawrence CountyClinton CountyColumbia CountyBerks CountyMercer CountySchuylkill CountySullivan CountyNorthumberland CountyCambria CountyLackawanna CountyWyoming CountyChester CountyMonroe CountyYork County

Private wells are a minority supply in York County yet still serve an estimated 47,384 homes, 25% of the county total. (EPA 2020 domestic water source estimates, 2020)

Aquifers and Well Depth in York County

Several aquifers lie under York County: Piedmont and Blue Ridge crystalline-rock aquifers covers 58% of the county, and Early Mesozoic basin aquifers (32%) and Piedmont and Blue Ridge carbonate-rock aquifers (10%) add to it. (USGS principal aquifers map)

The median domestic well is 200 feet deep, and half of them fall between 140 and 280 feet. Based on 20,688 well records. (PA DCNR PaGWIS)

What Is in York County Well Water

From 752 homeowner samples tested by Penn State's lab (2007-2025). Owners often test because they suspect a problem, so this is not a random survey. Penn State county summary

Coliform bacteria turned up often: 46% of 722 homeowner samples (2007-2025) tested positive, close to the Pennsylvania rate of 44%.

About one in 9 wells had nitrate above EPA's 10 mg/L limit: 11% of 382 homeowner samples (2007-2025), well above the Pennsylvania rate of 4%.

E. coli was found in 8% of 722 homeowner samples (2007-2025), lower than the Pennsylvania rate of 11%.

Tests for arsenic mostly came back under the EPA limits.

Median hardness is 4 grains per gallon (68.4 mg/L), about the same as the Pennsylvania median of 5 gpg, in the moderately hard range. Based on 317 homeowner samples, 2007-2025.

Expect nuisance issues from manganese (14% of homeowner samples over EPA's 0.05 mg/L secondary standard).

pH was outside the 6.5 to 8.5 range in 42% of homeowner samples, which points to water that can corrode pipes.

Neighboring counties report a higher arsenic exceedance rate than this county's under 1%: Adams (9%), Dauphin (7%) and Cumberland (2%). That is the 53rd highest of 64 Pennsylvania counties with enough data.

ParameterMedianAbove limitTestedPennsylvaniaU.S.
Total coliform bacteriaany detection counts as positive46%722, 2007-202544%
E. coliany detection counts as positive8%722, 2007-202511%
NitrateEPA limit 10 mg/L4.6 mg/L as N11%382, 2007-20254%4%
ArsenicEPA limit 10 µg/L0 µg/Lunder 1%182, 2007-20256%7%
IronEPA secondary 0.3 mg/L0.1 mg/L9%298, 2007-202517%19%
ManganeseEPA secondary 0.05 mg/L0.01 mg/L14%298, 2007-202522%21%
Hardness4 gpg317, 2007-202560%
Total dissolved solidsEPA secondary 500 mg/L147 mg/L1%657, 2007-20256%15%
ChlorideEPA secondary 250 mg/L12.9 mg/L2%56, 2007-20252%
SulfateEPA secondary 250 mg/L10.1 mg/L0%60, 2007-20252%
pHoutside 6.5 to 8.56.7 pH units42%657, 2007-202517%

"Above limit" counts homeowner samples over the listed limit; the U.S. share comes from USGS domestic well sampling, 1991-2004.(Penn State AASL) (USGS Circular 1332)

Radon: EPA radon Zone 1, the highest (indoor air potential, not a water test). (EPA Map of Radon Zones)

Where Private Wells Are Common in York County

Private wells are mostly a rural matter here: 90% of homes on wells sit outside town and community boundaries. (EPA 2020 domestic water source estimates, 2020)

  • Susquehanna Trails (unincorporated community): about 783 homes on wells, 85% of housing
  • Winterstown: about 231 homes on wells, 90% of housing
  • Pleasureville (unincorporated community): about 224 homes on wells, 22% of housing
  • Valley Green (unincorporated community): about 212 homes on wells, 16% of housing
  • Felton: about 174 homes on wells, 86% of housing
  • Fawn Grove: about 163 homes on wells, 80% of housing

Estimates, not exact counts (EPA 2020 model, Census 2020 housing).

Testing Your Well in York County

A good first lab panel here covers coliform bacteria, nitrate, total dissolved solids, pH, manganese and hardness. The first four are EPA's yearly basics; the rest come from the county records above. (EPA) Sampling steps and costs: how to test well water.

Pennsylvania Rules for Private Wells

No state rule sets how a Pennsylvania household well is built or how often it is tested; over a million homes rely on one. (Penn State Extension)

Frequently Asked Questions

Is well water in York County safe to drink?

Many wells are fine, but the records show coliform bacteria (46% of tested homeowner samples testing positive), nitrate (11% of tested homeowner samples over the limit) and E. coli (8% of tested homeowner samples testing positive). A lab test for those, and for bacteria each year, tells you where your well stands.

Is coliform bacteria a problem in York County well water?

46% of 722 homeowner samples were positive for total coliform bacteria and 8% for E. coli. A positive result usually means surface water is getting into the well; shock chlorination and a well cap or casing repair are the usual fixes.

Is nitrate a problem in York County well water?

Since 1990, 11% of 382 tested homeowner samples topped the 10 mg/L nitrate limit. Infants under six months are most at risk, so never mix formula with untested well water, and do not boil it: boiling concentrates nitrate.

Is there lead in York County well water?

19% of 211 samples drawn after water sat overnight exceeded EPA's 15 µg/L action level, a plumbing problem more than an aquifer one.

Should I test for radon in York County?

Yes: the county is in EPA Radon Zone 1, the highest. Radon can come in through well water as well as soil, so start with an air test.

How hard is well water in York County?

The median homeowner sample tested at 4 grains per gallon (68.4 mg/L as calcium carbonate), based on 317 homeowner samples. Many households manage without a softener at that level.

How deep are private wells in York County?

Around 200 feet at the median, with the middle half at 140 to 280 feet, from 20,688 well records.

Nearby Counties

Adams County Cumberland County Dauphin County Lancaster County

Sources and Data Notes

USGS principal aquifers map, EPA 2020 domestic water source estimates, 2020 Census, EPA Map of Radon Zones, USGS Circular 1332, Penn State AASL, PA DCNR PaGWIS, EPA, Penn State Extension, Pennsylvania Department of Health. Retrieved 2026-10-27.